All over the news, internet, and blogs this morning. Number one search term at Technorati: Ted Haggard.
The story:
A leading evangelist and outspoken opponent of gay marriage has given up his post as president of the National Association of Evangelicals while a church panel investigates allegations he paid a man for sex.
The Rev. Ted Haggard resigned as head of the 30 million-member association Thursday and also gave up leadership of his New Life Church pending the investigation into allegations he had monthly trysts with a gay prostitute over the past three years.
Haggard, a married father of five, denied the allegations, but the acting pastor of his church later said that Haggard had acknowledged some of the accusations were true.
“I just know that there has been some admission of indiscretion, not admission to all of the material that has been discussed, but there is an admission of some guilt,” Ross Parsley told KKTV-TV of Colorado Springs.
Parlsey did not elaborate, but in an e-mail addressed to congregants, he wrote that the church’s four-member board of overseers had since met with Haggard.
“It is important for you to know that he confessed to the overseers that some of the accusations against him are true. He has willingly and humbly submitted to the authority of the board of overseers, and will remain on administrative leave during the course of the investigation,” the e-mail stated. A copy was obtained by KMGH-TV in Denver.
Late Wednesday, Haggard told KUSA-TV: “I’ve never had a gay relationship with anybody, and I’m steady with my wife, I’m faithful to my wife.”
The allegations surfaced as voters in Colorado and seven other states get ready to decide Tuesday on amendments banning gay marriage. Besides the proposed ban on the Colorado ballot, a separate measure would establish the legality of domestic partnerships providing same-sex couples with many of the rights of married couples.
So, what is it? Unfounded allegations designed to sway the vote in Colorado, where two initiatives are on the ballot that would have an effect on same-sex marriage? Or, is it a true accusation of wrongdoing, that Haggard will have to answer for?
It looks to me as if (too) many, on both sides, have already made up their minds. Every time something like this happens, and by “something like this,” I mean a high-profile religious leader accused of hypocricy of a high order, people on both sides rush to judgement, rather than being patient, and letting the fact come through.
For instance, the quotes of church members in the above article:
Members of Haggard’s 14,000-member megachurch were stunned.
“It’s political, right before the elections,” said Brian Boals, a New Life member for 17 years.
Church member E.J. Cox, 25, called the claims “ridiculous.”
“People are always saying stuff about Pastor Ted,” she said. “You just sort of blow it off. He’s just like anyone else in the public eye.”
Or, in this article from 9 News in Colorado:
Many members of the church reacted to the news with disbelief.
“There is no truth to this at all. I’m disappointed because I loved him as a senior pastor and it’s just sad to see him move on like that,” said Chris Herndon, a church member.
“He loves God, he loves his people, his wife, his family and he would never do anything like this,” said Adrienne Simmonds, another church member.
I understand that you love and adore your minister, especially one who is so prominant in the Evangelical world…but hold out the possibility that, as all of us Christians (should) believe, people are fallible sinners. It is a surety that your minister is a sinner. That doesn’t mean that he had an ongoing homosexual relationship with a male escort…but it does mean that the allegations could possibly be true.
From the other side, there is a rush to condemnation, as, it looks obvious that the man is guilty. Headlines all over the place have already assumed Haggard’s guilt. The headline at Non-Prophet: Ted Haggard Confesses, which, unfortunately, Kathy repeats. When you read the email sent out by Haggard’s former church to its members, it doesn’t say he confessed, it states:
Since that time, the board of overseers has met with Pastor Ted. It is important for you to know that he confessed to the overseers that some of the accusations against him are true. He has willingly and humbly submitted to the authority of the board of overseers, and will remain on administrative leave during the course of the investigation.
A confession. But, a confession to what? Without the full information, it is impossible to know which part he confessed to (the sex, or the meth use). Either way, yes, he is guilty of something. We don’t know what, and it is misleading, at least at this point, to assume guilt on all counts. All I’m saying is, let’s give the man a fair shake. Then again, such public figures rarely are afforded one. The comments over at Non Prophet begin with this one:
Damned! I was right that he was gay!
Now it’s true.
For three years, that bastard has deceived church goers and making money..
And preaching religion on stage when he is a fairy.
What an asshole
Is the guy guilty? I don’t know. The evidence is mounting - alleged voicemails, verified by an expert, a letter from Haggard with cash, the “confession” that some of the allegations have merit.
Will it have an effect on the election in Colorado? I doubt it. Evengelicals are going to vote against same-sex marriage, regardless of what Haggard does. Maybe it will disgust and motivate some voters, maybe sway some moderates…who knows? I honestly don’t care all that much.
What disturbs me, if anyone is interested, is that if the allegations prove true, Haggard will be the latest in a long line of prominent evangelicals publically disgraced. Not that that disturbs me all that much - evangelicals, like everyone else, are fallible, sinners, and prone to engage in the acts that they simultaneously disown. That is the nature of the human spirit in this tension between the ages - already forgiven, not yet made perfect.
Further, when such a public figure falls, maybe that should be handled publically. It shows the world that the church is involved in disciplining its community, in love, compassion, and forgiveness. That could happen.
No - what frustrates me is that, if proven true, the hypocricy of Haggard will be spread by opponents of Christianity, and especially of Christianity’s appearance in politics, as a characteristic if all who would identify with the name of Christ. In essence, the sin of the one become’s characteristic of the whole. By doing this, the accusers will seek to undermine the validity and authority of any argument that the Christian right makes, politically or otherwise. And, I’m not really sure that is all that fair.
For more:
Confederate Yankee
Donklephant
KKTV News
Reformed Chicks Blabbing
La Shawn Barber’s Corner
For an example of my major concern, check out the response, in the comments, on some of the Left’s blogs:
The Huffington Post
DailyKos
Tags: Ted Haggard, Christianity, Sin, Human Fallibality
theology, news, politics | 2 Comments »